TD 3.5% Savings | General comparisons | Discussion forum

Please consider registering
guest

sp_LogInOut Log In sp_Registration Register

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search

— Forum Scope —




— Match —





— Forum Options —





Minimum search word length is 3 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

sp_Feed Topic RSS sp_TopicIcon
TD 3.5% Savings
October 21, 2008
12:55 pm
Earl
Guest
Guests

Just got a mailing from TD Canada Trust advertising 3.5% rate from now until March 31/09. I currently have an ING Direct account at 3.0%, so I guess it makes sense to move my money to the higher TD rate. Would appreciate any advice on this.
Earl

October 22, 2008
2:55 pm
Nina
Guest
Guests

I got the same promotion. It is a good one. Though temporary. I allready bank with TD so it simplifies banking for me.

The catch is that you only get the rate for a balance of $5000 or more and you can only make one withdrawal a month. Additional withdrawals cost $5/withdrawal.

So it is worthwhile if you have the cash and no great need to do frequent withdrawals.

ICICI has a 3.4% offer without the TD restrictions.

October 22, 2008
4:48 pm
Maxime
Guest
Guests

Wow these are really BAD condition.

5$ per withdrawal

OMG

October 23, 2008
1:23 am
pebbz
Guest
Guests

I might be interested in this deal as I already bank with TD. How did you hear about the promotion? I was tempted with their GIA, but it gives a measely 2.25% with the same conditions, so I went with ING direct instead. Was the promotion addressed specifically to you? Or was it just a flyer in the mail?

October 24, 2008
9:55 am
Salty Bob
Guest
Guests

I just received a flyer in the mail yesterday, advertising a 3.75% interest rating on all new deposits until 30 Nov 2008 - for PC Financial. Not worth the trouble for me for that short of time. By the time I get the account created, I would only get a week or two of this rate..! Those already have an acct should go for it!

October 24, 2008
8:13 pm
Earl
Guest
Guests

The offer was addressed specifically to me. Small print says the offer is valid for the recipient named only. I already have an RRSP with TD and have made noises about transferring it elsewhere.

Thanks for the info about just one free withdrawal per month. I will have to be careful about that. I might have considered the ICICI account but have heard too many complaints about them.

November 15, 2008
10:43 am
Bud
Guest
Guests

I just closed a TD savings account there are just too many fees and rules. Averaging $12/ month and often times more. Opened an account with PC great rates, no fees and checking also use CIBC atm's for free. Check em out! Another good one is Canadian tire Less flexible then PC but good rates too. STOP the Major Bank and TRust company service charge gouging!

November 17, 2008
4:28 pm
Snipes
Guest
Guests

High Interest accounts are for savings... not for "spendings"...
There should be no need to withdraw from one of these accounts on a regular basis. That is why you carry a regular savings or chequing account.
Anything above and beyond your regular spending/transaction needs is what should be saved in this account.

But then again, based on that reasoning... You are better off to forgo the high interest savings accounts that everyone offers, and save in a non-registered money market fund - which often carry higher interest rates than savings accounts...

One step further, hold it in Canada's new TFSA (Tax Free Savings Account) available Jan 2nd... which would give you an even greater savings than the traditional savings accounts - high interest accounts included!!

Snipes
Consultant

November 19, 2008
3:05 am
bobby
Guest
Guests

You should check out Vancity's Jumpstart Highinterest savings account. Currently at 3% has been that way for quite some time. Also fights poverty.

November 28, 2008
4:12 pm
fari
Guest
Guests

Hi,
I want to open an account with some bank. Anybody knows which bank is giving the best rates now on saving account with less or no resistrictions.
thanks

November 28, 2008
6:16 pm
Max
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 212
Member Since:
November 26, 2008
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

HSBC got the best rate till next March 3.75%.

ICICI bank got the best overall rate (3.10%) when no banks are offering promos and they give 20$ bonus when you sign up with them and deposit 100$

HSBC got far better money accessibiliy if you need debit card and debit transactions or bill payment over the Internet.

When HSBC is not offering any promotion, I send all my money to ICICI, when HSBC wakes up, I transfer all my money to HSBC.

I do not know aobut TD however because I'm a QC resident and do not have access to any other instutition other than ING, HSBC and ICICI.

The day you become free is the day you work for fun.

November 29, 2008
11:20 am
Doug
British Columbia, Canada
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 4291
Member Since:
December 12, 2009
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

TD Canada Trust has lots of branches in Quebec. You must live way up in northern Quebec or something, Max. 🙂

Cheers,
Doug

November 29, 2008
3:36 pm
Palos Green
Guest
Guests

Is Canadian Tires 4.3% for first 90 days not the best rate? Plus $20 signup bonus, plus another $25 bonus when you set up an automatic deposit of $25 or more.

I say sign up to all three, start with the bulk of your money at Canaidan tire for 3 months, get the bonus $, then transfer it to HSBC for the last month of their promo rate, then over to ICICI at least until a better rate comes along, and get the $20 bonus.
but don't forget to deposit $100 in a citizens account and grab the $50 bonus they're offering..

December 2, 2008
12:00 pm
djino
Ottawa (Gatineau, Qc Area)
Member
Members
Forum Posts: 310
Member Since:
December 12, 2008
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Max said:

I do not know aobut TD however because I'm a QC resident and do not have access to any other instutition other than ING, HSBC and ICICI.


Yeah, if you are in the Montreal/Outaouais regions, you should see plenty TD machines

djino
"Non TD Client, is it possible to just walk-in to a TD and only get that savings account?"

December 2, 2008
2:38 pm
nelboski
Guest
Guests

Bud said:

I just closed a TD savings account there are just too many fees and rules. Averaging $12/ month and often times more. Opened an account with PC great rates, no fees and checking also use CIBC atm's for free. Check em out! Another good one is Canadian tire Less flexible then PC but good rates too. STOP the Major Bank and TRust company service charge gouging!


I hear you Bud! Don't bother trying to get the rate from TD unless you were specifically solicitied for the deal (ie - received the promotion in the mail). I inquired about the deal (after banking with TD for several years with good standing), and they wouldn't offer me a thing. That was the last straw for me. I made the switch to PC. I don't get gouged with unnecessary fees, I have access to all CIBC ATM's, I can switch money between chequing and savings accounts for free, and I ALWAYS get a competitive return on my highly flexible savings account.

Once you figure out how much money you are burning at the big five banks, you'll make the switch too!

December 7, 2008
12:17 pm
SueC
Guest
Guests

Hey Everyone,
I had no idea these other financial institutions offered better deals than TD, which is across the street from where I live, so the convenience is great. However, there is supercenter up the street from me which has a PC financial station set up in it.

Regarding the PC rates, do you have to keep a minimum balance in your chequing account to avoid fees? With TD, I have to have $1000 in my account at all times or I am charged a crazy fee.

Any feedback would be great!
Thanks,
Sue

December 8, 2008
1:20 am
Peter
Admin
Forum Posts: 1449
Member Since:
May 15, 2007
sp_UserOfflineSmall Offline

Hi Sue,

For the PC Financial chequing account, there is no minimum balance. In other words, if you have only 1 cent in that account, you should not be charged fees for normal transactions.

For the PC Financial savings account, if you have less than $1,000, you get a 1% interest rate on the entire balance. If you have more than $1,000, you get the higher rate (currently 2.75%) on the entire balance.

December 9, 2008
10:25 am
financier
Guest
Guests

why dont you open HSBC direct savings account giving 3.75% until march, instead of 3.5% in TD

Please write your comments in the forum.